Back to timeline
Verified
Policy
Background

Florida touts opposite approach: visitor bans, staff testing, and no COVID-positive discharges to nursing homes

Florida Governor Ron DeSantis publicly contrasted his state's approach with New York's, noting that Florida had banned nursing-home visits since mid-March and prohibited hospitals from discharging COVID-positive patients back into nursing facilities that could not isolate them, instead standing up COVID-only nursing facilities. AP reporting confirmed Florida barred the return of virus-positive patients to homes lacking isolation wards and required regular staff testing. DeSantis argued the discharge prohibition 'saved a lot of lives,' while critics of Florida noted the state still recorded thousands of long-term-care deaths.

Primary quotes

Other
we prohibited discharging COVID positive patients back into nursing facilities, and that was the right decision to do — saved a lot of lives by doing that as prevented outbreaks.

Gov. Ron DeSantis, July 6–7, 2020 briefing (WKMG)

Flags / open questions

  • Dated to the July 2020 public articulation; the underlying policies date to mid-March 2020 per AP

Linked sources

Florida barred return of virus-positive patients to nursing homes without isolation wards (AP)
Tier 3 · news · July 2020; documents mid-March visit ban and discharge bar
Gov. Ron DeSantis reiterates commitment to curbing the spread of COVID-19 in long-term care facilities (WKMG)
Tier 3 · news · July 7, 2020 briefing transcript with the 'saved a lot of lives' claim

Related contentions

Did admission directives seed COVID-19 into nursing homes — and was the toll obscured?

Unresolved. The 50% undercount is confirmed by the NY AG, but the directive's causal share of nursing-home deaths was never adjudicated — the AG said only that it 'may have' increased risk, and DOJ declined CRIPA investigations in 2021; later data analyses (staffing levels, staff transmission) are cited by both sides without consensus.