Back to timeline
Verified
Policy

Great Barrington Declaration — Collins 'takedown' email

GBD called for Focused Protection. Collins emailed Fauci seeking a 'quick and devastating published take down.' Fauci publicly called the declaration 'ridiculous' / 'total nonsense.' Later central to Jan 2022 clash.

Primary quotes

Collins
There needs to be a quick and devastating published take down of its premises.

Email to Fauci, Oct. 8, 2020 (FOIA / court filings)

Fauci
That declaration has a couple things in it that I think are fooling people… So I think we've just got to look that square in the eye and say it's nonsense.

ABC Good Morning America, Oct. 15, 2020

Linked sources

Prepared Statement of Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, House Select Subcommittee (HHRG-118-IF16)
Tier 1 · transcript · Congressional record quoting the Oct 8 2020 Collins 'quick and devastating published take down' email verbatim
The Great Barrington Declaration
Tier 4 · other · The declaration itself (Focused Protection, Oct 4 2020)
Francis Collins moved to shut down Covid-19 dialogue between scientists (STAT)
Tier 3 · news · Dec 2021 coverage of the FOIA-released email; Collins confirmed authenticity
Wenstrup Issues Key Takeaways from Interview with Dr. Francis Collins (SSCP release)
Tier 2 · other · Quotes the Oct. 8, 2020 'quick and devastating published take down' email; majority-framed
Fauci transcribed interview, Day 2 (SSCP, January 2024)
Tier 1 · transcript · Contains questioning on the Collins 'devastating takedown' email

Related contentions

Public-health policy

Policy history documented; scientific consensus evolved; political dispute remains.